If you believe what Dan Pink is selling, as managers and process creators we have a lot of work to do. Motivation, it seems, has little to do with carrots and sticks and more to do with autonomy.
We can’t forget that we are leading people. We must keep in mind that business process management is more than flow charts. We aren’t leading monkeys or robots, but people who want to enjoy what they’re doing. I’ve talked before about creating business processes and consistently re-evaluating business processes. When defining the work instructions It’s important to focus on the non-negotiable tasks of the process. Does everyone need to do everything the exact same way? Probably not.
As Dan points out, the carrot rewards do work for simple tasks. If a task or process is repetitive it probably makes sense to use a carrot reward. Things along the lines of, “If you sew X number of bags, you’ll get Y bonus”. These simple tasks that have prescriptive instructions can be “carrotized”. However, these carrot rewards do not work for complex tasks that most of us do everyday. Telling your staff, “Figure out this problem that we’ve never seen before by X day and you’ll get Y reward”, produces poor results. Dan relays that this scenario has the potential of causing a tunnel vision. The focus is on the reward, not the result. Imagine the implications this has in Sales organizations.
So what can we do for our processes?
- Build in autonomy where appropriate. Are all tasks time or location dependent? Probably not. Look into a Results Only Work Environment.
- Focus on the results not the specific actions that everyone takes to get there.
- Ensure the inputs and outputs are solid, and the hand-offs defined. For the most part, your people should be smart enough to figure out the tactical execution.
- Set Expectations. Make sure everyone throughout the process understands their responsibilities and time lines. Nothing will break sabotage a process more than unclear expectations.
Treat people as people and you’ll be surprised how they respond.
Check out Dan’s TED talk below.
Posted by David Hottal at 10:32 am on January 27th, 2010.
Categories: Business Management, Business Process. Tags: management, Motivation, Process.
How often do you hear someone say, “It’s not my problem.” Well, that line of thinking is the problem. A problem for one part of the organization always impacts you.
If you are in sales, do you not think problems in customer service impact you? Try selling for an organization that has poor service levels.
Are you in supply chain? Do you ignore accounts payable issues? Try getting credit from a supplier that always gets paid 60 days late.
Too much focus is on the task at hand. Everyone in the organization needs a basic understanding behind the theory of your business. By having a clearer view of the interdependencies we can all see that one group’s problem is everyone’s problem. As managers we must enforce accountability, flatten the organization and properly apply empowerment.
Give your folks some latitude and you’ll see an increase in ownership and pride in the outcome.
Am I full of it? Let me know in the comments.
Posted by David Hottal at 7:08 pm on October 27th, 2009.
Categories: Business Management. Tags: management, Motivation, Project Management, teamwork.
Let’s get something straight. Just because your business card has “Manager” in the title, it does not mean that you have a management style. If your title is manager you fall into one of five categories:
- You are grossly unqualified to manage yourself, let alone a group of employees.
- You aren’t really a manager. Your boss just thought it would make you feel important. You are really just a supervisor, and #1 may apply.
- Your an excellent ass kisser, and #1 and #2 apply.
- Your manager fits into one of the first three categories, and subsequently, so do you.
- You are actually a manager. You take managing your employees seriously. You are concerned with getting the most out of your staff and meeting the goals of your organization.

Is this you?
I don’t have any statistics on this, but I would guess that only about 1 in 100 fall into category 5. I have heard way too many managers say, “That’s not my management style.” Listen, 90% of people have only a personality, not a management style.
If you are a manager, take a look in the mirror, and if you don’t fall into category 5, start doing some research. If you are in category 5, double check. If your focus is on the task, and not result, you actually fall in one of the first four categories.
Anyone can learn to be a good manager, but like anything it else, it requires effort. People aren’t born good managers.
Posted by David Hottal at 7:53 pm on August 10th, 2009.
Categories: Business Management. Tags: management, management style.
How’s that for a title with alliteration! I’ve been working in a corporate environment for the past 14 years, and one

Corporate Cruelty Crushes Creativity
thing that I’ve learned above all else, is that corporate culture crushes creativity. It’s probably not a conscious decision, but it is definitely a bi-product of control. Corporations are all about control. Trying to set policies and procedures that the worker bees can’t deviate from. There is too much ego, too much posturing, too much control, and not enough trust.
How many jobs ask the employee to leave their brain at the door? I’ve been in meetings where the managers actually say, “We don’t pay our people to think.” If I didn’t care about keeping my job, I would reply, “Well the CEO pays you to think, and if you actually did, you’d realize that you are an idiot!” This mindset is brought about by managers thinking the employees are just going to F things up. When in reality, it is the manager’s poor leadership that causes the issues.
More… »
Posted by David Hottal at 7:22 pm on August 10th, 2009.
Categories: Business Management. Tags: corporate culture, creativity, team structure, the goal.
Everyone knows there are problems in business, but they are not just financial. The economy is hurting, business are going under, or laying of workers. These things are all symptoms of a much bigger problem. Managers are all at 30,000 feet, or in some cases only on ground level.
A manager, whether it is of people or projects, must find the appropriate balance between being high level and being in the weeds. Decisions must be made based on the details with an eye on the future. Without an appropriate balance, decisions are being made with out seeing the whole situation. Managers that are not concerned with the details can make decisions that negatively impact their employees. How can a manager who doesn’t understand what an employee does, make quality decisions? They can’t. How can a manager who can’t see beyond the details make a decisions that aligns to a strategy? They can’t.
More… »
Posted by David Hottal at 8:35 pm on July 20th, 2009.
Categories: Business Management. Tags: business, details, manage, strategy.